Extradition from San Marino to Australia: Legal Help

Extradition from San Marino to Australia

No extradition treaty between Australia and San Marino has been identified, and Australia is not a party to the European Convention on Extradition, which San Marino applies with European states. An Australian request is therefore governed by San Marino’s Law No. 41 of 31 March 2014 on extradition, which applies in the absence of applicable international conventions (Article 1). The 2014 law replaced a single provision of the Criminal Code that, as the European Court of Human Rights noted in 2012, contained no procedural rules. For how Australia itself handles extradition, see our overview of Australia’s extradition framework.

Under the 2014 law, extradition cannot be granted without a favourable decision of the Judge of Appeal (Giudice d’Appello), which may be appealed to the Highest Judge of Appeal, and the Secretary of State for Justice then takes the final decision within 45 days. Citizens of San Marino may not be extradited except for the terrorism and subversion offences listed in the law.

Because a favourable judicial decision is a precondition and the executive must decide within a fixed period, both the hearing before the Judge of Appeal and the time limits matter. We work with Sammarinese counsel on each stage and coordinate with Australian criminal defence lawyers on the underlying charges.

The Legal Framework for San Marino–Australia Extradition

IssuePosition under Sammarinese lawPractical importance
Legal basisLaw No. 41 of 2014, where no international convention applies (Article 1)No treaty with Australia has been identified
CitizensNot extradited, except for terrorism and subversion offences (Article 4)A near-absolute bar
Extraditable offenceConduct that is an offence in both San Marino and the requesting state; no minimum penalty (Article 3)Dual criminality is the test
Decision-makersJudge of Appeal; appeal to the Highest Judge of Appeal; Secretary of State for Justice (Articles 7, 9 and 11)A favourable court decision is required
Provisional measuresRevoked if the request does not arrive within 40 days (Article 13)A firm early deadline
Executive decisionWithin 45 days, or a detained person is discharged (Article 11)A firm deadline for the Government

⚖️ INTERNATIONAL EXTRADITION & RE-SURRENDER DEFENCE

Facing Extradition to Australia? Secure Specialized Defence Early

Australian extradition frameworks under the Extradition Act 1988 involve rigorous cross-border procedures, strict minimum sentence thresholds, and complex dual criminality evaluations. Acting decisively before an arrest or final executive surrender opens the critical window needed to analyze procedural flaws, uncover human rights risks, and deploy proactive legal barriers against detention.

Request an Extradition Case Assessment 🔒 Strict Attorney-Client Privilege · Comprehensive Cross-Border Strategy

How an Australian Request Moves Through the Sammarinese System

Request and Documents

The request must include the judgment or detention order, a statement of the facts with time, place and legal classification, the applicable legal provisions and identification data (Article 6). The Secretary of State for Justice transmits it to the Judge of Appeal within 15 days (Article 7).

The Judge of Appeal

Extradition cannot be granted without a favourable decision of the Judge of Appeal, who decides within three months; the judge must refuse if criminal proceedings have been instituted, or a final judgment rendered, in San Marino for the same offence (Articles 7–8). The requesting state may take part in the proceedings through a local lawyer, subject to reciprocity (Article 10).

Appeal

The person, the Procuratore del Fisco or the requesting state may appeal to the Highest Judge of Appeal within 30 days (Article 9).

The Secretary of State’s Decision

After a favourable decision, the Secretary of State for Justice decides within 45 days; if no decision is made in time, a detained person is discharged. Surrender takes place within 15 days, which may be extended by 20 days (Article 11).

Provisional Measures

In urgent cases, the Judge of Appeal may order a precautionary measure before the extradition request is received. The measure is revoked if the request and documents do not arrive within 40 days, and measures lapse after eight months without a favourable decision, or one year if the case is on appeal (Article 13).

Grounds for Refusing Extradition from San Marino

Under Articles 3, 4 and 8 of the law, extradition is refused where:

  • the conduct is not an offence under both Sammarinese law and the law of the requesting state;
  • the offence is political, although terrorist offences are never treated as political;
  • there are substantial grounds to believe the person would be prosecuted or discriminated against on account of race, religion, gender or nationality, or subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment;
  • criminal proceedings have been instituted, or a final judgment rendered, in San Marino for the same offence;
  • the person is a citizen of San Marino, unless the offence is one of the terrorism or subversion offences listed in the law.

Citizens of San Marino

Article 4 of the 2014 law provides that a San Marino citizen cannot be extradited except for the terrorism and subversion offences listed in the law. If extradition is refused, Sammarinese judges must, at the requesting state’s request, start criminal proceedings (Article 4).

Consent and Speciality

If the person consents in the presence of counsel, the Judge of Appeal’s decision is limited to validating the consent, but consent does not oblige the Secretary of State to grant extradition (Article 7). Consent should only be given after specialist advice.

The person may not be detained or re-extradited for another offence committed before surrender; the protection ends if they remain more than 30 days after final discharge (Article 5).

Death-Penalty Assurances

The 2014 law allows extradition for an offence carrying the death penalty only if it is guaranteed that the penalty will not be imposed or carried out (Article 4). This does not create an obstacle for Australia: Australia has abolished the death penalty in all of its jurisdictions, so a person surrendered to Australia cannot be sentenced to death for the Australian charge.

How Our Extradition Lawyers Assist

In San Marino, we first establish citizenship and whether the conduct is an offence under Sammarinese law, then work with local counsel on the hearing before the Judge of Appeal, the 30-day appeal and representations to the Secretary of State for Justice. We monitor the 40-day and 45-day deadlines and coordinate with Australian criminal defence lawyers on the underlying charges.

No lawyer can guarantee the outcome of an extradition case. In San Marino, the result depends on the courts’ decisions and the Secretary of State’s decision.

Disclaimer: This information is provided for general guidance only and does not constitute legal advice. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and specific legal consultation is essential for anyone facing extradition proceedings.

FAQ

Is there an extradition treaty between San Marino and Australia?

No bilateral treaty has been identified, and Australia is not a party to the European Convention on Extradition. San Marino applies its Law No. 41 of 2014.

Can citizens of San Marino be extradited to Australia?

Only for the terrorism and subversion offences listed in the 2014 law. Otherwise, citizens are not extradited and may be prosecuted in San Marino instead.

Who decides an extradition request in San Marino?

The Judge of Appeal must first give a favourable decision, which may be appealed to the Highest Judge of Appeal; the Secretary of State for Justice then decides within 45 days.

Is there a minimum penalty for extradition from San Marino?

No minimum penalty is set. The test is that the conduct is an offence under both Sammarinese law and the law of the requesting state (Article 3).

How long does Australia have to send the request after a provisional measure?

Forty days; otherwise the measure is revoked (Article 13).

Are death-penalty assurances needed for extradition from San Marino to Australia?

Australia has abolished the death penalty in all of its jurisdictions, so a person surrendered to Australia cannot be sentenced to death for the Australian charge. Death-penalty assurances are therefore not normally an issue when Australia requests extradition from San Marino.