When Australia seeks the return of a person who is in Brazil, the request is decided in Brazil under the Treaty on Extradition between Australia and the Federative Republic of Brazil, signed at Canberra on 22 August 1994 and in force since 1 September 1996, together with the Brazilian Constitution and the Migration Law (Law No. 13.445/2017). For how Australia itself handles extradition, see our overview of Australia’s extradition framework.
Every extradition from Brazil requires a prior ruling by the Federal Supreme Court (Supremo Tribunal Federal) on its legality, and there is no appeal from that ruling. Native-born Brazilians can never be extradited.
Our extradition lawyers advise people in Brazil, and their families, where Australian federal, state or territory authorities are seeking their return. We review the Australian request, work with Brazilian counsel before the Federal Supreme Court, and coordinate with Australian criminal defence lawyers on the underlying case.
The Legal Framework for Brazil–Australia Extradition
| Issue | Position under the treaty and Brazilian law | Practical importance |
| Legal basis | 1994 treaty, in force since 1 September 1996; Constitution; Law No. 13.445/2017 | The treaty and Brazilian law apply together |
| Brazilian nationals | Native-born Brazilians are never extradited; naturalised Brazilians only in limited cases (Constitution, Article 5 LI) | Nationality is decisive |
| Threshold | Treaty: at least one year’s imprisonment; Brazilian law: refusal where the Brazilian penalty is less than two years (Article 82) | Lower-level offences are at risk of refusal |
| Decision-makers | Ministry of Justice, then the Federal Supreme Court, then the Executive authorises surrender | The Supreme Court’s ruling is mandatory and final |
| Provisional arrest | Release if the request is not presented within 60 days of arrest (Article 11 of the treaty) | A short early window |
| Removal | Australia must remove the person within 50 days of receiving the decision (Article 12 of the treaty) | Otherwise the person is released |
⚖️ INTERNATIONAL EXTRADITION & RE-SURRENDER DEFENCE
Facing Extradition to Australia? Secure Specialized Defence Early
Australian extradition frameworks under the Extradition Act 1988 involve rigorous cross-border procedures, strict minimum sentence thresholds, and complex dual criminality evaluations. Acting decisively before an arrest or final executive surrender opens the critical window needed to analyze procedural flaws, uncover human rights risks, and deploy proactive legal barriers against detention.
How an Australian Extradition Request Moves Through the Brazilian System
Diplomatic Channel and Ministry of Justice
The request is communicated through diplomatic channels with a Portuguese translation (Articles 7–8 of the treaty). It is received by the Ministry of Justice and Public Security, which checks the formal requirements and forwards it to the Federal Supreme Court (Decree No. 9.199/2017, Article 269).
Judgment by the Federal Supreme Court
Under the Constitution, the Federal Supreme Court hears extradition requests from foreign states at first instance (Article 102). No extradition may be granted without the Court’s prior ruling on its legality, and there is no appeal from that decision (Law No. 13.445, Article 90). The defence must be filed within 10 days of the person’s interrogation and may address only the person’s identity, defects in the documents or the illegality of the extradition (Article 91).
Authorisation by the Executive
If the Supreme Court finds the request admissible, the Ministry of Justice and Public Security assesses whether the person meets the requirements to be extradited (Decree No. 9.199/2017, Article 271). If extradition is refused at the judicial stage, a new request based on the same facts is not allowed (Law No. 13.445, Article 94).
Provisional Arrest Before the Formal Request Arrives
A request for provisional arrest may be sent through INTERPOL. Under Article 11 of the treaty, the person must be set at liberty if Australia fails to present the extradition request within 60 days of the arrest. Detention may otherwise continue until the Supreme Court’s final judgment, and the Court may allow house arrest or release with conditions (Law No. 13.445, Articles 84 and 86).
Which Australian Offences Can Support Extradition?
Under the treaty, an offence is extraditable if it is punishable by deprivation of liberty for at least one year, or, for a convicted person, if at least nine months of the sentence remain to be served; fiscal and tax offences are included (Article 2). Brazilian law also provides for refusal where Brazilian law imposes a penalty of less than two years for the offence (Law No. 13.445, Article 82). Both thresholds should be checked for each charge.
Grounds for Refusing Extradition from Brazil
Brazilian Nationals
No Brazilian may be extradited, except a naturalised Brazilian for a common crime committed before naturalisation or for proven involvement in drug trafficking (Constitution, Article 5 LI). Under the treaty, if extradition of a national is refused, the case must be submitted for prosecution in Brazil, and nationality is determined at the time of the offence (Article 5).
Mandatory and Discretionary Grounds
Extradition is refused, among other grounds, where:
- the offence is political or a crime of opinion (Constitution, Article 5 LII), unless the act is principally a common criminal offence;
- the conduct is not a crime in both states, or Brazil has jurisdiction and intends to exercise it;
- the person has already been tried for the same facts, or proceedings are pending in Brazil;
- the limitation period has expired under Brazilian law or the law of the requesting state;
- the person would be tried by an extraordinary or ad hoc tribunal;
- the offence is purely military, or the request is made to persecute the person on account of race, religion, nationality or political opinion;
- the person has been granted refugee status or territorial asylum in Brazil.
The treaty also allows refusal where extradition would be incompatible with humanitarian considerations (Article 4).
Commitments Australia Must Give
Before surrender, Brazilian law requires the requesting state to commit, among other things, to credit time spent in custody in Brazil, not to re-extradite the person without Brazil’s consent, and to commute a life or death sentence into imprisonment with a maximum of 30 years (Law No. 13.445, Article 96). Because life imprisonment is available for some offences in Australia, this commitment is relevant in serious cases.
Consent, Speciality and Removal
A person may voluntarily surrender to the requesting state if they declare it expressly, are assisted by a lawyer and are informed of their rights; the Supreme Court still decides the request (Law No. 13.445, Article 87).
Under the speciality rule, a surrendered person may not be detained or tried for other earlier offences without Brazil’s consent, unless they return voluntarily or fail to leave within 45 days (Article 6 of the treaty). Australia must remove the person within 50 days of receiving the decision (Article 12 of the treaty); otherwise the person is released. Surrender is postponed while the person is prosecuted or serving a sentence in Brazil, or in cases of serious illness confirmed by an official medical report.
Death-Penalty Assurances
The treaty allows refusal for offences punishable by death unless an undertaking is given. This does not arise in practice for requests from Australia: Australia has abolished the death penalty in all of its jurisdictions, so a person surrendered to Australia cannot be sentenced to death for the Australian charge. The separate commitment on life sentences, described above, may still apply.
How Our Extradition Lawyers Assist
We review the Australian request and documents, establish nationality and refugee status, check each charge against the treaty and Brazilian thresholds and coordinate with Brazilian counsel on detention and the defence before the Federal Supreme Court. We also work with Australian criminal defence lawyers so that positions taken in Brazil do not undermine the defence in Australia.
No lawyer can guarantee the outcome of an extradition case. The result depends on the treaty conditions, the Federal Supreme Court’s judgment and the Executive’s decision.
Disclaimer: This information is provided for general guidance only and does not constitute legal advice. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and specific legal consultation is essential for anyone facing extradition proceedings.