When Australia seeks the return of a person who is in Italy, the request is decided under the Treaty of Extradition between Australia and the Republic of Italy, done at Milan on 26 August 1985 and ratified by Italy by Law No. 12 of 2 January 1989, together with Articles 697–722 of the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure, which apply where the treaty is silent (Article 696). Australia’s regulations giving effect to the 1985 treaty commenced on 1 August 1990, and the treaty replaced an earlier treaty of 1973. For how Australia itself handles extradition, see our overview of Australia’s extradition framework.
In Italy, extradition cannot be granted without a favourable decision of the Court of Appeal, which may be challenged in the Court of Cassation; the Minister of Justice then decides. Under the Constitution, an Italian citizen may be extradited only where an international convention expressly provides for it, and never for political offences.
Our extradition lawyers advise people in Italy, and their families, where Australian federal, state or territory authorities are seeking their return. We review the Australian request, work with Italian avvocati before the Court of Appeal and the Court of Cassation, and coordinate with Australian criminal defence lawyers on the underlying case.
The Legal Framework for Italy–Australia Extradition
| Issue | Position under the treaty and Italian law | Practical importance |
| Legal basis | 1985 treaty, ratified by Law No. 12 of 1989; Code of Criminal Procedure where the treaty is silent (Article 696) | The treaty takes priority |
| Italian citizens | Extradition possible only where a convention provides for it (Constitution, Article 26); the treaty allows refusal of nationals (Article 5) | Not automatic, decided case by case |
| Extraditable offence | Punishable under both laws by at least one year; at least six months of a sentence remaining (treaty, Article 2) | Minor offences do not qualify |
| Decision-makers | Court of Appeal must decide favourably; appeal to the Court of Cassation; decision of the Minister of Justice (Articles 701–708) | Judicial and ministerial stages both matter |
| Provisional arrest | Release 45 days after arrest without the full request (treaty, Article 13) | A firm early deadline |
| Removal | Surrender within 15 days of the agreed date, extendable by 20 days (Code, Article 708) | Otherwise the decree lapses |
⚖️ INTERNATIONAL EXTRADITION & RE-SURRENDER DEFENCE
Facing Extradition to Australia? Secure Specialized Defence Early
Australian extradition frameworks under the Extradition Act 1988 involve rigorous cross-border procedures, strict minimum sentence thresholds, and complex dual criminality evaluations. Acting decisively before an arrest or final executive surrender opens the critical window needed to analyze procedural flaws, uncover human rights risks, and deploy proactive legal barriers against detention.
How an Australian Extradition Request Moves Through the Italian System
Minister of Justice and Prosecutor General
The request is made through diplomatic channels with translated and authenticated documents (treaty, Articles 10–11). The Minister of Justice sends it within thirty days to the Prosecutor General at the competent Court of Appeal, who questions the person, records any consent and files submissions within thirty days (Code, Article 703).
Court of Appeal
Extradition cannot be granted without a favourable decision of the Court of Appeal (Article 701). The court decides in chambers within six months of the Prosecutor General’s submissions; a favourable decision and the person’s consent do not make extradition mandatory (Article 704). The court must refuse where the proceedings in the requesting state do not respect fundamental rights, where there is a risk of persecution or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, or where health or age reasons would entail exceptionally serious consequences (Article 705).
Court of Cassation
The decision may be challenged by an appeal to the Court of Cassation, including on the merits, and the court decides within six months (Article 706).
Decision of the Minister
The Minister of Justice decides within forty-five days; if no decision is made in time, a detained person is released (Article 708). The Minister does not proceed with a request that could compromise Italy’s sovereignty, security or other essential interests (Article 697).
Provisional Arrest and Custody
Provisional arrest may be requested through diplomatic channels, between the justice ministries or through INTERPOL. Under the treaty, the person must be released 45 days after arrest if the full request has not arrived (Article 13); the Code provides a 40-day period (Article 715). In urgent cases the police may arrest, and the person must be brought before the president of the Court of Appeal within 48 hours (Article 716). Coercive measures are revoked if no favourable Court of Appeal judgment is given within one year, or one year and six months where there is an appeal to the Court of Cassation (Article 714).
Which Australian Offences Can Support Extradition?
Under the treaty, the offence must be punishable under the laws of both countries by imprisonment for at least one year, or at least six months of a sentence must remain to be served. Attempts, participation and conspiracy are included, and the totality of the conduct is taken into account (Article 2).
Grounds for Refusing Extradition from Italy
Mandatory Refusal
Under the treaty and the Code, extradition is refused where:
- the offence is political, or there is reason to believe the person will be persecuted or discriminated against, or subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment (treaty, Article 4; Code, Article 698);
- the offence is purely military;
- a final judgment has been given in Italy or a third state, or prosecution is time-barred;
- the proceedings in the requesting state do not ensure respect for fundamental rights (Code, Article 705).
Discretionary Refusal
The treaty allows refusal where the person is an Italian national, where Italy has decided not to prosecute, where a prosecution is pending in Italy, or where the offence was committed wholly or partly in Italy (Article 5).
Italian Citizens
Article 26 of the Constitution allows the extradition of a citizen only where it is expressly provided for by international conventions, and never for political offences. The treaty with Australia allows Italy to refuse to extradite its nationals; in deciding, the Minister of Justice takes into account the seriousness of the offence, the interests harmed and the person’s circumstances (Code, Article 697). If extradition is refused, the case is submitted to Italian prosecutors at Australia’s request.
Consent and Speciality
If the person consents to extradition in the presence of defence counsel, there is no Court of Appeal hearing, and the Minister grants extradition unless a mandatory ground for refusal applies (Articles 697 and 701). Consent should only be given after specialist advice.
Extradition is always conditional on the person not being detained or prosecuted for an earlier act other than the one for which extradition was granted, or re-extradited; the protection ends if the person does not leave within 45 days of final release (Code, Article 699; treaty, Articles 17–18).
Death-Penalty Assurances
The treaty allows refusal for offences punishable by death unless assurances are given (Article 6). This does not create an obstacle for Australia: Australia has abolished the death penalty in all of its jurisdictions, so a person surrendered to Australia cannot be sentenced to death for the Australian charge.
How Our Extradition Lawyers Assist
We review the Australian request and documents, establish citizenship, check the charge against the treaty threshold and coordinate with Italian avvocati on custody, the Court of Appeal hearing, any appeal to the Court of Cassation and representations to the Minister of Justice. We also work with Australian criminal defence lawyers so that positions taken in Italy do not undermine the defence in Australia.
No lawyer can guarantee the outcome of an extradition case. The result depends on the treaty conditions, the courts’ decisions and the Minister of Justice.
Disclaimer: This information is provided for general guidance only and does not constitute legal advice. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and specific legal consultation is essential for anyone facing extradition proceedings.